Rod Serling

Self - Host

Joanna Pettet

Elaine Latimer (segment "The House")

Joanna Pettet

Rhona Warwick (segment "The Caterpillar")

Gary Collins

Dr. Michael Rhodes

Susan Strasberg

Ruth Asquith (segment "Midnight Never Ends")

Susan Strasberg

Sheila Trent

Geraldine Page

Frances Turchin (segment "Stop Killing Me")

Geraldine Page

Molly Wheatland

Geraldine Page

Mrs. Evans (segment "The Sins of the Fathers")

John Astin

Jonathan (segment "Pamela's Voice")

John Astin

Munsch

John Astin

Randy Miller (segment "Hell's Bells")